How to Make Felt Starfish: A Detailed Guide from an Experienced Crafter

Emily

Created by

Emily

Last updated on 2025-12-03T12:11:58.776Z

Hello friends! If you’ve found your way here, I’m thrilled to share with you one of my all-time favorite crafting projects: making felt starfish. These adorable marine-themed creations are not only a delightful addition to any craft collection but also make fantastic gifts and decorations for coastal-themed events. Whether you’re looking to brighten up a child’s room or create a unique centerpiece for a beach wedding, felt starfish can bring a slice of the ocean right into your space.

Crafting has always been my go-to outlet for creativity, and felt starfish are particularly special to me because they remind me of those sun-soaked days by the sea. As a mother, I love that this project is perfect for crafters of all ages, making it a wonderful way to bond with kids while letting our imaginations run wild.

In this article, I’m going to walk you through my tried-and-true method for creating these whimsical starfish, step-by-step. We'll cover everything from materials to tips for perfecting your craft. Let’s dive in!

Why Felt Starfish?

Felt starfish are popular for a variety of reasons. They’re soft to the touch, easy to shape, and versatile to decorate. You can use them as toys, embellishments for home décor, or even as part of a fun learning project about marine life. Felt is a forgiving medium, making it perfect for novices and seasoned crafters alike.

Materials Needed

Before we get started, let’s gather our materials. You’ll need:

  • Felt fabric: Choose colors like soft peach, vibrant turquoise, or classic yellow; you may even want to incorporate glitter felt for a sparkly touch.
  • Embroidery thread: Pick shades that complement your felt fabric.
  • Needles: A sharp needle specific for embroidery or crafts.
  • Scissors: A good pair of fabric scissors is essential.
  • Fabric glue (optional): Good for securing layers, especially if you’re crafting with kids.
  • Stuffing: Use polyester stuffing or cotton balls to give your starfish some body.
  • Marker or chalk: For tracing your starfish template.
  • Template: I’ll guide you on how to create a simple starfish template.

Creating Your Starfish Template

To start off, let’s create a template for your starfish. If you're handy with a pencil, you can freehand a starfish shape, but I recommend using the following simple template to ensure an even design:

  1. Draw a five-pointed star: Make sure each arm is evenly shaped and about 4-6 inches long.
  2. Add a curved line at each arm: This gives the starfish its distinct, rounded look.
  3. Cut it out: You'll now have a starfish template to trace onto your felt.

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Felt Starfish

Step 1: Trace Your Shapes

Using your template, trace two starfish outlines onto your chosen felt fabric. This forms the front and back of your starfish. Remember, the colors you choose can reflect your personality or the theme you have in mind. Feel free to mix and match!

Step 2: Cut the Felt

Carefully cut out your felt starfish shapes. Take your time here; jagged edges can throw off the entire look. A good tip is to hold your scissors as if you’re pointing them at the shape as you cut, allowing for more control.

Step 3: Embroider the Details

Using embroidery thread, you can add embellishments! Some creative ideas include:

  • Stitches along the edges: A simple running stitch or blanket stitch in a contrasting color can reinforce the edges and add a pop of color.
  • Sprinkles of detail: Stitch small circles of different colors along the arms for added quirkiness.

What to watch out for: If your thread tangles, don’t rush—be patient and slowly unwind it. Keeping your stitches consistent will give a polished look.

Step 4: Assemble Your Starfish

Once you're happy with the embroidery, take one of your starfish pieces and place it right side up. Place the second piece on top, right side down. There should be a sandwich effect now, with the pretty sides of the felt facing inwards. If needed, you can dab a little fabric glue between the layers to hold them together while you sew.

Step 5: Sewing the Edges

Using a back stitch or a simple running stitch, sew around the edges of your starfish, leaving a 1/4 inch seam allowance. Remember to leave a small gap—about 1 inch—unsewn so you can turn the starfish right-side out later.

Step 6: Turn It Inside Out

Gently pull your starfish through the gap you left unsewn. This can be tricky; use a chopstick or the eraser end of a pencil to carefully push out the points of the star without ripping the fabric.

Step 7: Stuff Your Starfish

Once your starfish is turned right-side out, it’s time to stuff it! Fill each arm generously, but not to the point of bursting. If you find it difficult, try stuffing one arm at a time and using a pencil to help push the stuffing deeper into the arms.

Step 8: Sew It Closed

Once stuffed, fold the raw edges of the opening inward and stitch it closed using a ladder stitch, which is nearly invisible. This adds the final touch and completes your starfish.

Creative Variations

Once you've mastered the basic felt starfish design, consider trying some fun variations:

  • Add eyes: Use small buttons, beads, or stitched felt to create cute eyes.
  • Different shapes: Experiment with changing the shape of the starfish or making mini versions by scaling down the template.
  • Themed colors: Create starfish in colors that match a particular theme or holiday—think reds and whites for Christmas or pastels for Easter.

Tips & Tricks for Success

  • Choosing felt: If you're unsure about what kind of felt to use, wool felt is great because it holds shape well and feels luxurious. Craft felt is more affordable and perfect for kids.
  • Practice safety: Be mindful of scissors and needles. Always supervise children if they are crafting with you.
  • Mistakes happen: If you make a mistake or aren’t satisfied with a stitch, it's completely okay. Just unpick the stitches carefully and try again!

Final Thoughts

Creating felt starfish is a fun and satisfying project that allows for endless creativity. I hope this guide inspires you to dive into your own crafting adventure. Remember, every crafter started somewhere, and it’s the journey and joy of creating that matters most.

So gather your materials, unleash your creativity, and enjoy making these delightful ocean wonders! I'd love to hear how your felt starfish turn out, so feel free to share your creations or any questions you may have in the comments. Happy crafting!